United by music, though the first Eurovision Song Contest Asia is still finding its voice—and not for lack of volume
The winner, the Philippines’s Carmelle
A “song contest” today is quite a different event from what we imagine it to be. In fact, such competitions have outgrown the human voice. Volume is vital, both in vocal and performance output. How they use their vocal cords is perhaps now less important than how they use their bodies. It is total packaging, and hitting the note is merely the entry fee. It has been this way for a while now, particularly since the launch of American Idol (then under Fox) in 2002, during which the show operated less like a pure vocal competition and more like a traditional record label audition designed to manufacture mainstream pop stars. Fast forward to the present, during last Saturday’s debut Eurovision Song Contest Asia, it was painfully evident that the bar has shifted from mere vocal adequacy to a rigorous test of endurance and spatial management—as though a high C is utterly worthless unless delivered while executing a frantic, calorie-shedding floor routine.
Before skipping genially ahead, there is the small matter of what the organisers have called it. Eurovision is one of those institutions that makes perfect sense if you’re European and slightly absurd if you’re not. The original Eurovision grew organically in the 1950s out of European public broadcasters attempting to unite a fractured, post-war continent, evolving over time into a peculiar annual ritual. There is a reason the franchise has struggled to take root outside Europe. Eurovision Asia, by stark contrast, is the money-minded brainchild of Western commercial producers licensing intellectual property—an arrangement that puts brand uniformity ahead of local cultural ownership. That template was duly reprised in Bangkok three days ago. And as it has been in Europe, the winner is less interesting than the spectacle itself. Watching the livestream of the staging at One Bangkok, we quickly realised that this is not primarily a song contest. The music is the excuse.
The second place went to Thai duo Mang and Daou
So, the name effectively says, here’s Asia’s version of a European institution. Even if that is not what the organisers intended, it still came across that way to us. We can’t imagine if Europe launched an international contest called AsiaVision Europe. Would the Europeans not immediately wonder why their continental identity was being framed as a derivative of somebody else’s? Even non-Europeans would. Football fans would understand this analogy: There is already the UEFA European Championship and we have the Asian Cup. Neither feels subordinate to the other. There has been aggressive social media marketing on the part of Eurovision—the lineage of the one in this part of the world had been clear. But not only did Eurovision keep its name, it retained the executive team, at least initially, but following a last-minute US$1 million budget cut, the international crew walked out and was replaced by Thais. The Euro-centric posturing unsurprisingly drew criticisms that flying in European and American producers to dictate television formats and cultural values to Asian broadcasters felt somewhat “semi-colonial”. Even if semi, in Thailand, that would be felt.
If there were any doubt that Europe remains the true centre of gravity here, the broadcast schedule settles it. The live broadcast in Bangkok began at 19:30 local time (or 20:30, our time) specifically so it would air at 14:30 CET—a comfortable Saturday afternoon slot for European YouTube viewers. Nothing here suggested a format built from the ground up for Asia; it looked, rather transparently, like an exercise in accommodating European tastes and viewing habits first. Even the judging would not be a head-scratcher to the European fans of the show. To take the coveted crown at Eurovision Song Contest Asia, an act has to survive a near-50/50 split between 11 national music juries and an international online public vote. Each neutral jury, domestic fanbase, and an ill-defined twelfth “Rest of the World” bloc ranks their top ten from 1 to 12 points—ensuring the eventual winner isn’t necessarily the best song, just the most palatable compromise between industry suits and debit-card-wielding internet voters, who gets eight free votes before they have to pay for extras. The catch, as co-host Cindy Bishop gleefully announced: those eight free votes cannot all be dumped onto a single favourite. Voters are required to distribute them across at least three different entries.
In third place, Vietnam’s Tóc Tiên
A political scientist may recognize the mechanism immediately. It’s not a search for a majority favourite. Rather, it’s a search for the strongest coalition. Perhaps, who won did not matter. At the end of the two-and-a-half-hour broadcast, we did not remember a single song. That, we think, is a damning indictment. Memory is the ultimate test. Nobody leaves a football match remembering the sponsor banners or, to be more consistent with this column, leaves a fashion show remembering the exits of the venue. We are in the fifth paragraph and have discussed many things, but we do not remember a single song title, not even a hook that we could hum repeatedly in our heads. Even today, when Eurovision itself has become far more spectacle-oriented, its strongest entries still tend to survive as songs. You can sing them years later. Songs like Waterloo escaped the competition and entered popular culture. What we saw instead was an event where the songs were merely the delivery mechanism for processed performance packages.
For a “song contest”, the numbers were as immaterial as the “Asia” in its moniker. The winning song was really the winning performance. Had it been judged with the eyes closed, the result might have been rather different. Carmelle (Collado), 19, sang with a gravelly voice and won. Two months ago, the 16-year-old Thai contestant of America’s Got Talent, Nene Royal, also sang in a similar vocal colouring and emerged victorious. We are not suggesting that both of them have anything in common other than the roughened voice. The shared factor is not Thailand, the Philippines, or America; it is competition television. And to compete on screen, they needed the performance to override the singing. Nene had her guitar and could really bang it. Carmelle had her hips and could really work the floor. Different tools, but they served the same function. The conclusion we came to was that a “song contest” is no longer a match of singing. The contestants compete to occupy the screen. Carmelle was a total performance ecosystem in one body. She was not only able to prance and shake to the Shakira-esque rhythm, she was able to cavort on the floor. And she was the only one who did.
Malaysia’s Aina Abdul was placed fouth
Carmelle’s winning performance showed how uneven the playing field was. Her closest competitor was Vietnam’s Tóc Tiên, placed third, but her performance was hopelessly crippled by that saccharine, ethereal routine, inspired by the mainland Southeast Asian pop cliché, the lotus flower. And there was Malaysia’s Aina Abdul, detonating the stage with vocal force. But Ms Abdul was placed fourth. Her song, Bluest Sky—as evocative as lotus flowers—allowed her to belt at her most ferocious, but it did not sound like spontaneous self-expression or conducted in service of the tune. To us, it sounded almost optimised—for the big stage and bigger broadcast. Ms Abdul had another disadvantage. She must appear in massive gowns. That is her stage signature. But here in Bangkok, she also laboured under the distinct disadvantage of refusing to make horizontal acquaintance with the stage floor. Ms Abdul may have the voice, but the package that she came in was for a static performance Eurovision had little interest in. If the contest was judged as a total performance package, then contestants were hardly stepping onto the stage with the same theatrical arsenal, especially those who would not treat the stage as an aerobics floor.
All of which makes the second-ranking finish of Thailand’s Mang & Daou rather harder to grasp. The Thai entry sounded to us like the exact inverse of the winning act (or the excellent opener Bangkok Sounds and Senses). An ambitious nod to daytime Thai melodrama, the performance itself seemed to be the high school singing club’s cover of it. A TV theme song is designed to support a story. With the dramatic context stripped away, the song’s emotional cues had nowhere to go—except, perhaps, toward the male co-performer’s distracting, freshly shaved underarm over the dislodged earset microphone during the costume change. Whatever Carmelle did, she made a choice. Perhaps too many choices. Or every choice available. But a choice nonetheless. The Thai song, conversely, made no choice at all. It simply occupied the middle of the road. That usually gets you run over. Somehow, it landed Thailand second place. The famous Thai hospitality came with quiet rewards.
Screen shots: eurovisionsongcontest/YouTube



